The Great Debate: Gesture vs Voice (2023)

The great debate: gesture versus voice

The Great Debate: Gesture vs Voice (1)

In linguistics, the question of which came first, the gesture or the voice, is a long-standing debate. The answer to this question has implications for how we understand the origins of language.
On one side of the debate are those who believe the gesture came first. The argument for this view is that gesture is a more fundamental form of communication than voice. Gestures are more flexible and can be used to communicate a wider range of meanings than speech.
On the other side of the debate are those who believe the voice came first. The argument for this view is that voice is a more efficient form of communication than gesture. Speech can be used to communicate more complex meanings than gestures and can be used over a greater distance.
So far there is no clear answer to the question of which came first: the gesture or the voice. Debate continues, however, and new research may provide insight into the origins of the language.

Although gestures have proven to be progenitors in the past, they are now supported both lexically and syntactically as predictors of language.

Language is also based on gestures, that is, on actions.

Although the gestural nature of the language can be seen in forms likesign languageand handwriting, it is more difficult to define a gestural system in language, the dominant form of speech in the modern world. Gesticulate, gesticulate is a commonly used verb (not to contradict).

The word "gesture" derives from a Latin root "gerere" which means "carry or bear, assume, undertake, perform or achieve" and is used in everyday life.

(Video) Debate Gestures

What is the origin of the gesture?

The Great Debate: Gesture vs Voice (2)

Linguists supported themgesture theoryof language development for many years, and several recent studies have done so.

According to a study, hand-coded languages ​​are easier to learn than spoken languages, and some deaf communities also use them. Gesture theory of language development offers a more comprehensive understanding of language and is better suited to understanding the wide range of languages ​​spoken around the world. It's likely that thegestural formof communication was the beginning of the spoken form, and the study of both forms is required to fully understand the language. What is the natural gesture?

Are gestures the origin of human language?

Seatheory of gestural origin, Language evolved from early gestural interaction. Is the movement inherited or natural?

The importance of sign language for parents and children

The wave of "Hello" is one of the most common expressions. When parents greet their children, they feel welcome and cared for. Thumbs up, pointing, nodding and agreeingcommon gestures. Because sign language is universal, whatever language a child speaks or hears will be understood by both parents. Children with disabilities should be able to use sign language more easily. Autism can make it difficult for some children to speak, but they still have the ability to gesture. A child with autism can use sign language to communicate with others. To communicate with children it is important to use sign language, but there are other ways. Speak clearly and express your feelings appropriately and help your child understand what you are saying. Sign language is one of the many methods parents can use to communicate with their children. Communication is universal, and both vocalizations and gestures play an important role in language development.

Why did early humans use gestures?

Researchers don't know what the first language looked like in history, and it's unclear what it looked like when humans first spoke it.

What was the first form of language?

The Great Debate: Gesture vs Voice (3)
(Video) Decoding debate body language

According to some, the first truly spoken language is the proto-language of Homo habilis. Others instead claim descent from Homo erectus, while most instead claim descent from Homo sapiens. The origins of the language are a hot topic, but the prevailing view is that all languages ​​descended from a single proto-language that arose around 50,000 years ago.

The spoken language is generally believed to have evolved tens of thousands of years before the written word. A similar period is believed to have occurred in China and Egypt around 3000 BC. C. was when the earliest evidence of writing was recorded. the protohuman language(aka Proto-Sapiens, Proto-World) may be the direct genetic ancestor of all languages ​​spoken in the world. There are many theories about the origin of language, but the prevailing view is that all languages ​​are the product of a single proto-language that arose around 50,000 years ago. The written language was developed in the early 3000s to preserve spoken languages. Many people today use written language to communicate, which is believed to have evolved from earlier forms of communication such as spoken language. When was the language invented?

The evolution of language

The results show that the language evolved between 50,000 and 150,000 years ago, around the time modern Homo sapiens evolved. When and who invented the first computer? The oldest written language on earth is Sumerian. Because it is an isolated language, it is not related to any other extant language used by the people of Sumer in southern Mesopotamia. How did the first language come about? There is even a possibility that the language began as a sign language before transitioning (gradually or abruptly) into song mode and eventually becoming a vestige ofmodern gestures. In addition, many other topics are examined, such as the effects of stress. People communicate through language, but they also use gestures: spontaneous movements of the hands and body that, like spoken words, take place anywhere in the world.

Do gestures belong to linguistics?

The Great Debate: Gesture vs Voice (4)

Contrasted with other movements, segments or meaningsgestural formsand functions are assigned meaning based on their appearance and function. Children use gestures to communicate with each other before communicating with each other verbally.

When a child grasps a gesture, they can express themselves verbally for the first time. When a child uses a gesture, their listeners respond by saying something about what they heard, indicating they communicated in a language they can learn from. A gesture can be a powerful tool to help a child with communication, socialization, and developmental milestones. You can support your child's communication development by encouraging them to use gestures. What types of pragmatics are there in linguistics?

Do gestures belong to pragmatics?

According to Payrat*, (2009), non-verbal communication mechanisms (such as gestures) and verbal aspects of communication are at the heart of meaning formation in interactions.

(Video) R.S.V.P. - Clueless (1/9) Movie CLIP (1995) HD

Are gestures considered language?

The study of gesture has shown that it is an important part of language, as it forms a unified system with language and plays an important role in language and cognitive development.

What stage of language development are gestures at?

Between 9 and 12 months it is possible to develop the ability to use gestures. There are times when a child will hold up an object to show you or point to an object that they want to express their thoughts on. According to Kristi, this is a technique they use to interact and communicate with each other while opening and closing their hands to receive.

gesture and speech

Gesture and speech are two forms of communication that are often used together. When we gesture, we use our body language to communicate. This can include the use of our hands, facial expressions, and even our posture. When we speak, we use words to communicate. This can include the tone of our voice, the volume and the speed at which we speak.

Pacing gestures are currently being studied as a promising new tool for exploring the role ofnonverbal communicationin language comprehension. Linguists have identified tempo gestures as a mechanism for influencing a variety of linguistic features, including perceptions of lexical stress. One study found that heartbeat gestures can affect the perception of vowels, which is a crucial step in language learning. It's possible that making a heartbeat gesture can improve communication and understanding. By examining how tact gestures affect vowel perception, we will be able to better understand how speakers generate emotion and convey meaning.

The importance of gestures in communication

A person can use both their voice and their hands to communicate. In general, gestures convey meaning worldwide through visual and mimetic images, while language conveys meaning unobtrusively through code words and grammatical devices.
Nonverbal communication, such as body language or gestures, is an important way for speakers to express their emotions. The presence of a speaker's body can help emphasize and clarify the words they are using, while enhancing their sincerity and enthusiasm.
We found that rhythmic gestures affect explicit and implicit lexical stress perception (i.e. distinguishing object from object) as well as the extent to which vowels are distinguished based on rhythmic gesture. Although the gesture has different meanings for different people, it can be used to convey meaning in communication.

Example of oral gesture theory

Oral gestures, particularly those involving the mouth, lips, or tongue, could be considered similar patterns to those inphysical gesturesHow to greet. To show that early humans began waving their hands in the air instead of saying goodbye, we must first show how early humans began waving their tongues in the air.

Arespectful gestureIt is an action that enables the communication of a place or time. The pointing point is also used to determine the location of something or draw a circle with your hand to indicate its position. Motor gestures are movements that allow you to communicate an intention or thought. If you don't want something or are upset, clap your hands or shake your head. Symbolic gestures, which are visual cues representing a specific concept, are used to convey meaning. Raising a hand to show peacefulness or making a fist to show anger are examples. A gesture is a symbol that represents an action or an object. With the Hitler salute simply by raising your hands or with the peace sign simply by laying on your hands on your heart. There are many different metaphors for emotions or feelings; Metaphors are gestures used to express emotions or feelings. Rubbing your eyes to indicate you are tired or touching your forehead to indicate you are in pain can be used to indicate illness. A gesture conveys meaning globally, but a speech conveys meaning discretely using code words and grammatical devices. Language consists of coded words and grammatical devices, while gestures consist of visual images and facial expressions. We use all forms of gestures, such as B. Voluntary, motor, symbolic, iconic and metaphorical gestures. The meaning of different gestures can vary, but it is possible to develop a general concept of what each type of gesture represents. Besides iconic gestures used to encode specific meanings, these gestures can also be used to convey emotion or feeling. Metaphorical gestures are gestures that can be used to convey an emotion or feeling, as well as to express an idea or place. A gesture is a powerful tool for expressing ideas and emotions and can be used to communicate a wide variety of feelings and ideas. Although it is difficult to determine the meaning of a single gesture, it is possible to get a good understanding of the different types.

(Video) Rance Allen - "I Stood on the Banks of Jordan"

The Origin of Language: The Theory of the Oral Gesture

Seatheory of oral gestures, a gesture was the beginning of human language. They were unconsciously copied and formed into words through imitated gestures. This theory is found in the words "woof woof", "ding dong" and "oink".

First gesture hypothesis

Humans have been able to evolve language for 50,000 years (Hewes, 1999) according to the ancient belief that they were able to communicate symbolically.

monkey gestures

Chimpanzees displayed a greater variety of gestures in their gesture profiles than bonobos, such as raising their arms, forcefully touching, touching, and reaching out to touch, while bonobos displayed a greater variety of gestures, such as reaching out to touch hit the ground.

About the author


(Video) Buster Murdaugh Allegedly Made Rude Gesture Toward Witness

I quit my "comfy" job at Facebook to pursue my dream of teaching people around the world.


Did The Great Debaters beat Harvard? ›

The film depicts the Wiley Debate team beating Harvard College in the 1930s. The real Wiley team instead defeated the University of Southern California, who at the time were the reigning debating champions.

What is the difference between speech and debate? ›

What is the difference between Speech & Debate? Speech and Debate are one program with two seperate events: Speech involves invovles more 'performance' aspects than debate. Speech events are divided into two categories: Public Address and Interpretation.

Why were the Wiley debaters so successful? ›

The Wiley teams simply memorized his arguments and wrote them on file cards they could pull out to meet a point made by an opponent. Tolson was so good at finding holes in the logic of others his debaters rarely had to do it on their own. "And then we had to debate Tolson in practice.

What was the main message of The Great Debaters? ›

Rhetorical Analysis Of The Great Debaters

The purpose of this debate is to convince the audience whether or not civil disobedience is a moral weapon. Ms. Booke and Mr. Farmer believe that justice isn't divided equally, and that civil disobedience is a moral weapon in the fight of justice.

How accurate was The Great Debaters? ›

Three of the four debaters were fictional. The film's writers took half of the names of authentic debaters and changed their last names.

How fast do debaters speak? ›

1. “Fast” debaters speak at between 260 and 320 words per minute.

What are the 3 different debate formats? ›

Four types of debate
  • Parliamentary Debate.
  • Lincoln-Douglas Debate.
  • Cross Examination Debate.
  • Academic Debate.

What are the three parts of a debate? ›

Structure for Debate

A formal debate usually involves three groups: one supporting a resolution (affirmative team), one opposing the resolution (opposing team), and those who are judging the quality of the evidence and arguments and the performance in the debate.

What are 3 synonyms for debate? ›

synonyms for debate
  • argument.
  • contest.
  • controversy.
  • deliberation.
  • dispute.
  • match.
  • agitation.
  • altercation.

Did Wiley College beat Harvard in debate? ›

In 1935, the Wiley College debate team defeated the reigning national debate champion, the University of Southern California (depicted as Harvard University in The Great Debaters). In 2007, Denzel Washington announced a donation of $1 million to Wiley so the team could be re-established.

Did Harvard debate team loses to inmates? ›

When inmates in a New York maximum-security prison beat Harvard in a debate four years ago, their victory made international headlines and highlighted the intellectual talent behind bars. Now, the three debaters who outsmarted the Ivy Leaguers have a new round of accomplishments.

What was the Harvard debate about in The Great Debaters? ›

“The Great Debaters” concludes with a debate match between the small all-black Texas Wiley College and Harvard—shot in Sanders Theater. In the sequence, a debater from Wiley calmly but daringly calls on the mostly white audience to do something about racial violence and injustice in the South.

Who is Harvard's biggest rival? ›

The Harvard and Yale football rivalry, known as "The Game," is the second-oldest continuing rivalry in college football. The Crimson and Bulldogs are the two winningest teams in the FCS, have 26 national championships, two Heisman winners, and 32 Ivy League crowns.


1. The Secret Of Bill Clinton's Charisma
(Charisma on Command)
2. Charlton Heston Mark Antony speech "Julius Caesar" (1970)
(Arik Elman)
3. The surprising secret to speaking with confidence | Caroline Goyder | TEDxBrixton
(TEDx Talks)
4. How to Win a Debate, According to a 16-Year-Old Expert
(Inside Edition)
5. Debating skills - Debate Style: It’s all about how you say it
(HUB Scuola)
6. The Big Debate (ep. 1, Feb 17): Does Land Reform Threaten Our Future?
(SABC News)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ms. Lucile Johns

Last Updated: 01/03/2023

Views: 6369

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ms. Lucile Johns

Birthday: 1999-11-16

Address: Suite 237 56046 Walsh Coves, West Enid, VT 46557

Phone: +59115435987187

Job: Education Supervisor

Hobby: Genealogy, Stone skipping, Skydiving, Nordic skating, Couponing, Coloring, Gardening

Introduction: My name is Ms. Lucile Johns, I am a successful, friendly, friendly, homely, adventurous, handsome, delightful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.